Me: the projector is not a good model but the CNS data terminates there, with the immune cells and that, i posit, is what fires the motor neurons in the brain, driving the "motion picture" effect that is memory as memories are not static
Claude: "Memories are not static" holds up well. The hippocampus replays experiences as sequences, the order of events squeezed into a fraction of a second, mostly during sleep and quiet rest. When you recall an action, the motor areas fire as if you were rehearsing it. So memory behaving like a moving picture rather than a snapshot fits the evidence.
Bringing immune cells into it is also more defensible than most people would expect. Microglia, the brain's resident immune cells, prune synapses by tagging the weak ones with complement proteins and removing them. A 2020 study found that they drive forgetting this way. Astrocytes sit at synapses and adjust how strongly they transmit. So the immune side genuinely edits the memory network.
There are two places where I think it breaks:
- Glia don't fire neurons. Microglia and astrocytes don't produce the electrical spikes that drive motor neurons. They adjust the conditions: which synapses survive, and how easily a neuron fires. They act more like the projectionist than the projector bulb.
- There's no endpoint. CNS (central nervous system) signals don't end anywhere. They loop, from cortex to basal ganglia to thalamus and back to cortex, so "terminates there" is the weakest part of the claim.
The strongest link to your lipid work is timing. Oligodendrocytes, the cells that build myelin, add or thin it according to activity. That tunes how fast each pathway conducts, so signals in a sequence arrive in the right order. In film terms, lipids would set the frame rate and keep the reels in sync. That's a supportable claim that keeps fat in the motion-picture model without making it the place memories are stored. Whether that's a good fit for NAT-LDA is your call.