dopetalk

General => General Discussion for Everybody => Topic started by: Chip on August 14, 2015, 07:53:20 PM

Title: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Chip on August 14, 2015, 07:53:20 PM
all management roles are currently temporary until we reach a member count of 300

we thank those who have shown interest and those who have already contributed ... good on you !

LATER: the elections are now pending - we had an influx of members.
Title: Re: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Sand and Water on October 14, 2015, 10:34:41 AM
all management roles are currently temporary until we reach a member count of 300

we thank those who have shown interest and those who have already contributed ... good on you !

LATER: the elections are now pending - we had an influx of members.

Hey Chipper-i posted a question when i saw nicks thread about the elections - then saw it was in the temp mod subforum. All I can see on my screen right now is this thread on the Home page, so apologies if this is repetition

My questions:  can we include the option to nominate someone for mod/admin?  There are folks i think would be great. Of course, it would be made clear that there's no obligation to accept if elected. Also, will the voting be simply one vote per person & each vote counts the same (just like we do in elections here in the US)?
Title: Re: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Chip on October 14, 2015, 01:24:51 PM
Quote

Hey Chipper-i posted a question when i saw nicks thread about the elections - then saw it was in the temp mod subforum. All I can see on my screen right now is this thread on the Home page, so apologies if this is repetition

My questions:  can we include the option to nominate someone for mod/admin?  There are folks i think would be great. Of course, it would be made clear that there's no obligation to accept if elected. Also, will the voting be simply one vote per person & each vote counts the same (just like we do in elections here in the US)?

nick is currently exploring election models so i can't answer that yet.

the polling system is not very accommodating when it comes to things like elections.

but i hope so and expect so.

... just a word of advice for anyone keen to moderate: it's often a thankless and laborious job and if anything, it has a high potential to get members offside.

... and you have to stay current so there's a lot of reading about stuff that probably doesn't always interest you.
Title: Re: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Narkotikon on October 14, 2015, 01:35:44 PM
FWIW, Nick answered this in his thread (the temp mod one).  He said we ought not to nominate other people.  Being a mod / admin requires personal commitment, and the person has to exhibit that by choosing to put themselves forward.  So they need to nominate themselves. 

He also said nominating other people would make the process more confusing and less efficient. 

As for the voting re. number of votes, I'm assuming it will be one vote per person. 
Title: Re: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Chip on October 14, 2015, 01:41:30 PM
i modified the polling system to incorporate the use of a points system -- the mod went on today.

we will see if it can be of any use to us but just as an fyi, you may find a use for it yourself or any other pollsters.

please follow up on any suggestions as we are new to election voting-by-forum.
Title: Re: SMF Forum Moderators and Admins Roles During Board Genesis
Post by: Sand and Water on October 14, 2015, 06:49:18 PM
Quote

Hey Chipper-i posted a question when i saw nicks thread about the elections - then saw it was in the temp mod subforum. All I can see on my screen right now is this thread on the Home page, so apologies if this is repetition

My questions:  can we include the option to nominate someone for mod/admin?  There are folks i think would be great. Of course, it would be made clear that there's no obligation to accept if elected. Also, will the voting be simply one vote per person & each vote counts the same (just like we do in elections here in the US)?

nick is currently exploring election models so i can't answer that yet.

the polling system is not very accommodating when it comes to things like elections.

but i hope so and expect so.

... just a word of advice for anyone keen to moderate: it's often a thankless and laborious job and if anything, it has a high potential to get members offside.

... and you have to stay current so there's a lot of reading about stuff that probably doesn't always interest you.

Good morning :)  quick fyi : I replied in Ncks thread (as Nark referenced it) regarding my opinion re motivation etc. I appreciate you having to work with a challenge when creating a poll & thanks for the replies.
SimplePortal 2.3.6 © 2008-2014, SimplePortal