The Chain Reaction That Drives Evolution
Working argument, distilled 17 November 2026
The argument in one sentence
Wherever energy flows through matter in repeating cycles, whatever can remake itself faster than it is erased will accumulate, and every change it makes becomes the next pressure it must survive, so the reaction keeps going for as long as the energy lasts.
The loop: six links
- Energy and cycles. The Sun's light, gravity (Earth's spin, the Moon, the orbit) and Earth's internal heat drive repeating cycles: wet/dry, hot/cold, light/dark, tide, weather, season. Every cycle has a building phase and a breaking phase.
- React. In the building phase molecules join. The product carries its reactants' properties forward. This is inheritance before there is any copying.
- Preserve. The breaking phase erases whatever is fragile. What remains is tough, sheltered (on minerals, inside fatty droplets), mutually protecting (peptides bound to nucleotide strands), pure-handed, and selective about its partners. Much later this becomes immunity.
- Replicate. Among the survivors, those that tilt the next round toward more of themselves outnumber the rest. They do it by templating (shaping a neighbour into a copy) and by self-reinforcing loops (a product that speeds up its own making). Replication is preservation by remaking: being rebuilt faster than being destroyed.
- Modify / Grow. Copying is never perfect, and contents get mixed and exchanged: fatty compartments fuse and bud off with shuffled contents, and later cells swap genes, merge, and have sex. New variants appear.
- Feedback: the chaining link. Every new variant changes conditions for all the others. It uses up supplies, leaves waste, and becomes food, threat or partner. That creates new pressure and sends the loop back to link 3. Each solution makes the next problem. Copiers attract parasites, which forces defence, which forces counter-defence. Oxygen began as poisonous waste and became the best fuel.
The same loop at every level
| Level |
Replicate |
Preserve |
Modify / Grow |
| Molecules in pools |
Templating; self-reinforcing reaction loops |
Toughness; shelter on minerals and in fats; peptide and strand protecting each other |
Mis-joining; mixing when compartments fuse |
| Early cells |
Division |
Membranes; repair; defences against invading genetic material |
Copying errors; gene swapping between cells |
| Complex life |
Reproduction |
Immune systems; repair |
Sex; mutation; captured viral and jumping genes; cell mergers (mitochondria) |
Terms as used here
- Replicate: reactivity whose product carries its reactants' properties and tilts the next round toward more of itself.
- Preserve: resisting or outpacing breakdown. It becomes immunity once it can recognise an intruder and respond.
- Modify / Grow: change through imperfect copying and through exchange.
- Exchange: first of charge, energy, chemical groups and pattern; later of genes.
Where it will be challenged, and the reply
- "Never-ending?" Only while energy flows. The accurate claim is "self-sustaining for as long as the energy lasts". When the flow stops, everything returns to balance, which is death: for a cell, a body or a planet.
- "Chain or loop?" A loop that ratchets. Each turn starts from where the last one ended, and each turn triggers the next, which is why "chain reaction" is fair.
- "This is just Darwin." Largely, yes, and that is support. Replicate, Preserve and Modify line up with heredity, selection and variation. What this argument adds is running the same loop below life, down into chemistry, and treating exchange as a main engine of change. The chemist Addy Pross has argued something similar for the chemical stage.
- "Immunity that early?" No. At the start there is only preservation: toughness and choosiness. Immunity proper needs recognition of an intruder, which comes with cells. Concede this and the rest stands.
- "Is it proven?" Individual steps have been shown in the laboratory: peptides that copy themselves, chains forming under wet/dry cycling, compartments fusing and mixing contents. The full path from pool to cell has not been demonstrated. This is a framework consistent with the evidence, not a proven history.